top of page

For Referees

Guidelines for Referees

When you receive an invitation to peer review, you will be sent a copy of the paper's abstract to help you decide whether you wish to do the review. Try to respond to invitations promptly - it will prevent delays. It is also important at this stage to declare any potential Conflict of Interest. When you agree to review an article you will be asked to provide an analysis of merits, and your assessment on whether the article is suitable for publication in World Scholars Review.

Here are some tips on how to referee an academic journal article.

    1. Read the manuscript thoroughly and carefully

The first step in refereeing an academic journal article is to read the manuscript thoroughly and carefully. Take the time to understand the research question, the methodology used, the results obtained, and the conclusions drawn. Try to identify any potential flaws or weaknesses in the study, and consider whether the research is significant and original.

    2. Evaluate the manuscript objectively

As a referee, it's important to evaluate the manuscript objectively, without any personal biases or preconceptions. Avoid making any assumptions about the authors, their research, or their institution. Focus solely on the quality of the research and its contribution to the field.

    3. Identify any issues or concerns

If you identify any issues or concerns with the manuscript, be sure to document them clearly and provide specific examples to support your evaluation. Some common issues include:
 

  • Methodological flaws or limitations

  • Inadequate or unclear data analysis

  • Poorly articulated research questions or hypotheses

  • Lack of originality or significance

  • Incomplete or inadequate literature review
     

    4. Provide constructive feedback

When providing feedback to the authors and editor, be sure to provide specific, actionable suggestions for improvement. Avoid vague or general criticisms, and instead focus on concrete ways in which the research can be improved. For example, you might suggest additional data analysis, a more thorough literature review, or a clearer articulation of the research question or hypothesis.
 

    5. Be professional and respectful

It's important to maintain a professional and respectful tone when providing feedback to the authors and editor. Remember that the goal of peer review is to improve the quality of the research, not to criticize or attack the authors. Use constructive language and avoid personal or derogatory comments.

 

    6. Meet the deadline

Finally, be sure to meet the deadline for submitting your referee report. World Scholars Review has tight publication schedules, and delays in the peer review process can be costly and disruptive. If you're unable to meet your assigned deadline, let the editor know as soon as possible so that alternative arrangements can be made.

In conclusion, refereeing an academic journal article is a significant responsibility that requires careful attention to detail, objectivity, and constructive feedback. By following these tips, you can provide a valuable service to the scholarly community and help to ensure that the research published in World Scholars Review is of the highest quality.

bottom of page